Skip to main content

< Back to Main List | Groups Index

Urban Moving Systems

New Jersey moving company that employed the five Israeli nationals arrested on September 11, 2001 after witnesses reported them filming and celebrating the World Trade Center attacks. The company's owner fled to Israel before the FBI could complete its investigation.

FieldDetails
TypeFront Company / Intelligence Operation
FoundedUnknown (operational by 2001)
Location(s)Weehawken, New Jersey
Active PeriodPre-2001 to September 2001
StatusClosed (owner fled to Israel, September 2001)
OwnerDominik Suter
Key ClaimUrban Moving Systems served as a front for Israeli intelligence operatives who had foreknowledge of the 9/11 attacks and were positioned to document them
Evidence RatingSTRONG EVIDENCE

Overview​

Urban Moving Systems was a moving company based in Weehawken, New Jersey, that became the subject of an FBI investigation after five of its employees -- all Israeli nationals -- were arrested on September 11, 2001. The men were observed by multiple witnesses filming and apparently celebrating while the World Trade Center burned across the Hudson River.

The incident was first reported by The New York Times and Israeli newspaper Haaretz in September 2001. The FBI investigation, subsequently partially declassified through FOIA requests, revealed a case that was transferred from counter-terrorism to foreign counter-intelligence -- the squad responsible for investigating espionage by allied nations. The company's owner, Dominik Suter, fled to Israel before the FBI could conduct a follow-up interview.

The case intersects with the broader investigation documented by the DEA in 2001 of an extensive Israeli intelligence operation active in the United States before 9/11, in which young Israelis posing as "art students" were mapping the locations and movements of federal law enforcement personnel, including in areas where the 9/11 hijackers were living.

Key Activities & Evidence​

The September 11 Observations​

On the morning of September 11, 2001, shortly after the first plane struck the North Tower of the World Trade Center at 8:46 AM, a woman in an apartment building in Union City, New Jersey reported seeing three young men kneeling on the roof of a white van in the parking lot of her building. According to her account and the subsequent police report, the men appeared to be taking video or photographs of themselves with the burning World Trade Center in the background. She reported that they seemed to be celebrating -- high-fiving and displaying what she perceived as expressions of joy.

The woman called the police and reported the license plate number of the white van, which was marked with the logo "Urban Moving Systems."

The Arrest​

At approximately 4:00 PM on September 11, the white van was stopped by East Rutherford, New Jersey police on the approach to the George Washington Bridge. Five Israeli nationals were detained:

  1. Sivan Kurzberg -- Driver of the van
  2. Paul Kurzberg -- Sivan's brother
  3. Yaron Shmuel
  4. Oded Ellner
  5. Omer Marmari

According to police reports, when stopped, Sivan Kurzberg reportedly told officers: "We are Israeli. We are not your problem. Your problems are our problems. The Palestinians are the problem."

Evidence Found​

The police search of the van and the men's possessions revealed:

  • $4,700 in cash -- Hidden in a sock
  • Foreign passports -- Israeli passports for all five men
  • Box cutters -- The same type of instrument reportedly used by the hijackers
  • Maps -- With certain locations in New York City highlighted
  • Multiple cell phones
  • Photographs -- Later developed, showing the men posing and smiling with the burning WTC towers in the background

Bomb-sniffing dogs were brought to the scene and, according to reports, gave a positive indication for the presence of explosive traces on the van, though subsequent testing did not confirm explosive residue.

The FBI Investigation​

The FBI took over the investigation from local police. The case was initially handled by the counter-terrorism division but was subsequently transferred to Squad C-9 of the FBI's Newark, New Jersey field office -- a foreign counter-intelligence unit. This transfer is significant because foreign counter-intelligence units investigate espionage by foreign governments, including allied nations.

The five men were held in a federal detention facility in Brooklyn for approximately 71 days. During their detention, they were subjected to multiple interrogations and polygraph examinations. According to declassified FBI documents, Paul Kurzberg refused to take a polygraph test for approximately ten weeks before eventually taking one that he reportedly failed.

An FBI field report ultimately stated: "Both the Newark and the New York Divisions conducted a thorough investigation which determined that none of the Israelis had any information on prior knowledge regarding the bombing of the World Trade Center. Furthermore, Newark and New York determined that none of the Israelis were actively engaged in clandestine intelligence activities in the United States."

However, the case was classified, and significant portions of the FBI file remain redacted in declassified versions obtained through FOIA.

Dominik Suter and Urban Moving Systems​

Dominik Suter, the owner of Urban Moving Systems, was initially interviewed by the FBI on September 12, 2001. When agents returned for a follow-up interview shortly thereafter, Suter had fled to Israel. His departure occurred despite an active FBI investigation into his company.

Urban Moving Systems ceased operations immediately after September 11. The FBI found that the company appeared to have very few actual moving clients and that its business operations were inconsistent with a legitimate moving company.

Suter was placed on a "Be On Lookout" (BOLO) list by the FBI but was not extradited from Israel.

The Israeli Television Interview​

After their deportation to Israel in November 2001, three of the five men -- Oded Ellner, Yaron Shmuel, and Sivan Kurzberg -- appeared on an Israeli television talk show. During the interview, Oded Ellner made a statement that has been widely cited:

"Our purpose was to document the event."

This statement raised significant questions, as the first plane strike on the World Trade Center was not a foreseeable event that one could prepare to "document." If the men were already positioned with cameras to film the attacks as they happened, it implies foreknowledge of the event.

Connection to the Broader Israeli Intelligence Operation​

The Urban Moving Systems case exists within the context of a broader pattern documented in a 61-page DEA report from June 2001 that detailed an extensive Israeli intelligence operation in the United States. The report described approximately 140 young Israelis, many with military intelligence backgrounds, who were posing as "art students" and systematically targeting and surveilling the offices and homes of DEA agents and other federal law enforcement officials across the United States. Some of these "art students" were operating in the same geographic areas where the 9/11 hijackers were living, including Hollywood, Florida, and northern New Jersey.

Key Figures​

  • Dominik Suter -- Owner of Urban Moving Systems; fled to Israel before FBI could complete investigation
  • Sivan Kurzberg -- One of the five detained Israelis; driver of the van
  • Paul Kurzberg -- One of the five; reportedly failed polygraph; brother of Sivan
  • Yaron Shmuel -- One of the five detained Israelis
  • Oded Ellner -- One of the five; stated on Israeli TV "our purpose was to document the event"
  • Omer Marmari -- One of the five detained Israelis

Why This Group Matters​

The Urban Moving Systems case matters because it represents documented evidence -- police reports, FBI investigation files, eyewitness testimony, and the men's own public statements -- of Israeli nationals who appeared to have foreknowledge of the September 11 attacks. The key patterns:

  • Foreknowledge implied -- The men were positioned to film the attacks as they happened; one later stated their "purpose was to document the event"
  • Foreign counter-intelligence classification -- The FBI transferred the case to its espionage unit, indicating the bureau believed it involved foreign intelligence activity
  • Owner flight -- Dominik Suter's flight to Israel during an active FBI investigation is consistent with an intelligence operation being shut down
  • Classification of evidence -- Significant portions of the FBI file remain classified or redacted
  • No mention in official reports -- The incident received no coverage in the 9/11 Commission Report (see 9/11 Commission)
  • Broader pattern -- The case connects to the documented DEA report on an extensive Israeli intelligence operation active in the US before 9/11

Criticisms & Counter-Arguments​

  • FBI cleared them. The FBI's official conclusion stated that the men had no foreknowledge of the attacks and were not engaged in clandestine intelligence activities. Their detention and deportation were attributed to immigration violations.
  • Celebration may have been misinterpreted. The witness who reported the men may have misinterpreted their behavior. People react to shocking events in different ways, and filming a major event is not unusual.
  • "Document the event" may be poorly translated. The Hebrew-to-English translation of Ellner's TV statement may not convey the original meaning. He may have meant they wanted to record the aftermath, not that they had advance knowledge.
  • No explosive residue confirmed. While bomb-sniffing dogs initially indicated positive, subsequent laboratory testing did not confirm explosive traces.
  • Box cutters are common. Box cutters are standard tools for a moving company and their presence is not inherently suspicious.
  • Conspiracy theories have been exaggerated. Media coverage in conspiracy-oriented outlets has embellished and distorted the known facts of this case beyond what the evidence supports.
  • 9/11 Commission -- The official investigation that did not mention the Urban Moving Systems incident
  • PNAC -- The think tank whose agenda benefited from the attacks the Israelis appeared to have foreknowledge of
  • Pakistan ISI -- Another foreign intelligence service with documented connections to the 9/11 attacks

Other Coverage Worth Reading​

  • Philip Zelikow: The 9/11 Commission executive director who ensured the Urban Moving Systems case never appeared in the official report.
  • Bob Graham: The Senator who chaired the Joint Inquiry knew about foreign intelligence connections to 9/11 that were systematically suppressed.
  • 9/11 Commission: Given less money than the Clinton-Lewinsky investigation, the official 9/11 probe excluded WTC 7, Saudi connections, and Israeli intelligence.
  • PNAC: Fourteen members of a think tank that called for a "new Pearl Harbor" were placed in the Bush administration before 9/11.

Sources​

This information was compiled by Claude AI research.